Last week’s seminar with Colleen Deeny was a good introduction to the ethics and policy behind research. It was interesting to see how history’s ethical disasters and dilemnas were used to establish the current regulations researchers use today. Using humans in clinical trials is a very valuable practice yielding significant benefits to society, provided rules are followed. I have noticed that scientists often times view consent forms and IRB approval of new protocols as road blocks that delay schedules and create stress. We must, however, be grateful for the extensive measures taken to protect our study subjects.
I found the NY Times article very interesting, as I had never heard of a researcher fabricating data. Poehlman, clinical researcher at the University of Vermont, was caught and charged for this crime. He cheated rather boldly, initially using his authortitative position to deny his misdeeds. I give my kudos to Water Denino, the UVM student who courageously confronted his boss after asing the advice of many colleagues. Denino faced the possibilty of permanently damaging his career but knew it was the responsible thing to do. Poehlman brought up the issue of writing grants to obtain federal money to conduct research. My mentor once told me that as long as you have ”good data and good results”, getting funding is not that bad, just time consuming. It was noted that for one of Poehlman’s later studies, even a false hypothesis would have been a contribution to science.
I enjoyed And the Band Played On although I was saddened to learn that many ethical barriers prevented the CDC and Reagan administration from investigating AIDS sooner than they did. The most obvious ethical misdeed was done by Dr. Gallo, an egotistical researcher who wanted the credit for isolating the disease first done by French researchers. The subject of obtaining government funding to run a lab was also touched on in this movie. Dr. Curran of the CDC explained how time-consuming and competitive grants were- reasons his lab lacked adequate research equipment.